Teams Are Paying More For Guys To Defend Wide Receivers Than They Are For Actual Receivers

By on March 25, 2016 in ArticlesSports News

At one time, offense in the NFL was all about three yards and a cloud of dust – the running game. That era is long gone. Nowadays, if you can't pass, you are going to have a hard time winning games in the NFL. At the same time, if you can't defend against the pass, you are not going to have a hard time winning games.

As a result, a good passing quarterback can easily make $20 million a season. Elite wide receivers will make anywhere from $12-15 million, and elite defensive backs anywhere from $10-17 million. When guys become available, free agency teams will do whatever they can to lock up ones on their roster or steal one from another team.

Last off-season was a great year for wide receivers, with several elite players signing new deals. The total value of contracts for those elite guys was over $336 million. Add on the $237 million in free agent contracts, and it was a very good year to be a wide receiver.

This year – not so much.

With no elite receivers on the market, teams have had to compete for second tier guys. If they are lucky, they'll get one who will complement their current No. 1 receiver, or maybe even develop into an elite receiver. After about two weeks of free agency, teams have committed $142.09 million, with $65.48 million guaranteed.

 J. Meric/Getty Images
J. Meric/Getty Images

Only six guys have signed deals with a value of at least $10 million:

  • Marvin Jones, Detroit Lions, five years for $40 million
  • Mohamed Sanu, Atlanta Falcons, five years for $32.5 million
  • Travis Benjamin, San Diego Chargers, four years for $24 million
  • Rishard Mathews, Tennessee Titans, three years for $15 million
  • Jermaine Kearse, Seattle Seahawks, three years for $13.5 million
  • Mike Wallace, Baltimore Ravens, two years for $11.5 million

There are a few elite defensive backs who became free agents. They have signed their free agent tenders, but could still sign a mega-deal by July 15. As the numbers currently stand, teams are spending big this off-season to make sure they are better at defending against the pass next season.

After about two weeks of free agency, teams have committed $372.2 million and guaranteed $154.2 million. Seven players have signed deals valued at $20+ million:

  • Janoris Jenkins, New York Giants, five years for $62.5 million
  • Sean Smith, Oakland Raiders, four years for $38 million
  • Tashaun Gipson, Jacksonville Jaguars, five years for $36 million
  • Rodney McLeod, Philadelphia Eagles, five years for $35 million
  • Eric Weddle, Baltimore Ravens, four years for $26 million
  • Jeremy Lane, Seattle Seahawks, four years for $23 million
  • Adam-Pacman Jones, Cincinnati Bengals, three years for $20 million

As nice as this year's free agency period has been to guys who play in the secondary, it was even better last year. With Darrelle Revis and his five-year, $70.12 million deal leading the way, more than $470 million was committed to defensive backs, with $184.3 million guaranteed. Ten players signed deals worth $20+ million.

Al Bello/Getty Images
Al Bello/Getty Images

So is this a new trend? Have teams always spent more on defensive backs? The answer is yes (total $/guaranteed $):

  • 2016: Defensive backs-$372.2 million/$154.2 Wide Receivers-$142.09 million/$65.48 million
  • 2015: Defensive backs-$470 million/$184.3 Wide Receivers-$237.06 million/$107.9 million
  • 2014: Defensive backs-$479.6 million/$202.5 million Wide Receivers-$235.9 million/$92.98 million
  • 2013: Defensive backs-$328.2 million/$106.5 million Wide Receivers-$182.3 million/$73.3 million
  • 2012: Defensive backs-$338.9 million/$68.9 million Wide Receivers-$280.6 million/$57.3 million
  • 2011: Defensive backs-$361.2 million/$18.05 million Wide Receivers-$156.4 million/$16.4 million

With the state of the NFL being what it is, this isn't really that much of a surprise. For years, the rules have favored the passing game making it more difficult for defensive backs to excel. So, when there is one that appears to do an above-average job on the market, he is going to be in demand. Higher demand almost always translates into a higher salary, but teams need wide receivers too. So why does the same rule not appear to apply to them?

Easy – offense wins games, but defense wins championships. As much as everyone likes to win games, they like to win championships even more.

Did we make a mistake?
Submit a correction suggestion and help us fix it!
Submit a Correction